Data security is a very important issue that can have unpleasant consequences if not met. Over the years I have read a lot of 'holocaust' books, both fiction and non fiction, and thought this would be another typical book. When Eliezers father is sent to stand among those condemned to die, Eliezer runs after him. Meir Katz is among the dead. "When I see the impact my body made on the car it is a miracle I'm still alive": Former Irish champion Imogen Cotter looks ahead to the new season, twelve months after being hit head on by . To see what your friends thought of this book, Still Alive: A Holocaust Girlhood Remembered, (I read the German original, titled "Weiter leben: Eine Jugend"), what I most liked about this book was the way Kluger simultaneously asserts uncomfortable and contradictory things like: it's terrible when people assume that the catastrophe of the Holocaust must somehow have made people better, wiser, more loving, but it's also terrible when people don't recognise that survivors might have some special insight into some things; that silence and forgetfulness here is a terrible sin, but memorialisation is often empty and fetishistic; that survivors of this kind, what I most liked about this book was the way Kluger simultaneously asserts uncomfortable and contradictory things like: it's terrible when people assume that the catastrophe of the Holocaust must somehow have made people better, wiser, more loving, but it's also terrible when people don't recognise that survivors might have some special insight into some things; that silence and forgetfulness here is a terrible sin, but memorialisation is often empty and fetishistic; that survivors of this kind of atrocity have experienced something others can't begin to understand, and yet are, still, ultimately, denied access to the essence of this experience of mass murder, precisely because they survived, were the, (Reviewing it a year after reading.) I was 100% sure that I will die. Eliezer falsely tells Rabbi Eliahou he has not seen the son, yet, during the run, Eliezer saw the son abandon his father, running ahead when it seemed Rabbi Eliahou would not survive. Subscribe now. Use up and down arrows to review and enter to select. on 2-49 accounts, Save 30% THE SAME AS THE ONE YOU ORIGINALLY WROTE IN GERMAN? "[4] Despite her unhappiness, Klger still credits her mother's paranoia as the reason for her survival. Still Alive is a memoir of the pursuit of selfhood against all odds, a fiercely bittersweet coming-of-age story in which the protagonist must learn never to rely on comforting assumptions, but always to seek her own truth. Buy From Amazon. You can help us out by revising, improving and updating She and her mother are deported to various camps. About Kate Alice Marshall. Ms. Kluger wrote about her life from the time she was a little girl in Vienna through the horrors of WWII to life after the war. Shortly before he leaves, John brings Alice to their beach house for a final vacation. For the next 7 days, you'll have access to awesome PLUS stuff like AP English test prep, No Fear Shakespeare translations and audio, a note-taking tool, personalized dashboard, & much more! WHAT ARE SOME ACCURATE DEPICTIONS OF THE EXPERIENCES? Relatedly, Kluegers background as a poet shines in the ways that she destabilizes the chronological backbone of her narrative by interjecting things that happened long before or long after key events in question. Being a cancer cell biologist, John refused to believe what Alice was ill and tried to prove that diagnose was wrong. Some will be put off by Kluger's reluctance to remain likable, her lifelong feud with her mother and her propensity to condemn well-meaning platitudes, but every page of this book is dripping with the wisdom, honesty and reflection of a truly sage person. Chapter 4: The Rabbit Sends in a Little Bill. Deported to Theresienstadt at 11 with her mother. The author expresses many negative feelings within herself and her family, particularly her mother. One day John comes home with the news that hes been offered a position in New York City. Recipes for gefilte fish are no recipe for coping with the Holocaust. Together they have three kids, Anna (who is trying to conceive her first child with her husband, Charlie), Tom (a third-year medical student at Harvard), and Anna (who is pursuing acting in Los Angeles). The free trial period is the first 7 days of your subscription. !function(d,s,id) Still Alice Summary and Study Guide. A nurse, Carole, comes to take care of Alice, who no longer recognizes her children. This reportedly affected her desire to use faith as a means of coping with the Holocaust. For the next 7 days, you'll have access to awesome PLUS stuff like AP English test prep, No Fear Shakespeare translations and audio, a note-taking tool, personalized dashboard, & much more! Her husband is a Canadian psychology professor often considered the most influential public intellectual in the Western world. Macabre, witty, humorous, but overwhelmingly sad. (one code per order). Our, "Sooo much more helpful thanSparkNotes. (including. They examine the way that the Holocaust tests father-son bonds. From the creators of SparkNotes, something better. One day Alice secretly visits a care facility for dementia patients. Learn how and when to remove this template message, https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Still_Alive_(book)&oldid=1122951880, Wikipedia articles with plot summary needing attention from December 2018, All Wikipedia articles with plot summary needing attention, Articles needing additional references from October 2016, All articles needing additional references, Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike License 3.0, This page was last edited on 20 November 2022, at 21:08. RK: Shoah, the unforgettable documentary by Claude Lanzmann; the books by Primo Levi and Elie Weisel; This Way for the Gas, Ladies and Gentlemen by Tadeusz Borowski (Penguin); and Smoke Over Birkenau by Liana Millu (Northwestern University Press). According to online sources, she was born in the year 1968. What was her degree? While there, Alices graduate student, Dan, introduces her to his new wife, Beth, and they chat for a while before Alice excuses herself. For example, before transporting Auschwitz prisoners to Christianstadt, each woman's uterus was inspected for stray items: "there had been a 'gynecological' exam carried out by female prisoners, which was not for or about our health, but served the purpose of discovering whether we hid any precious items in intimate parts of the body. resource to ask questions, find answers, and discuss thenovel. This book blew my mind. Malnourished, exhausted, and weakened by his injured foot, Eliezer forces himself to run along with the other prisoners only for the sake of his father, who is running near him. Start by marking Still Alive: A Holocaust Girlhood Remembered as Want to Read: Error rating book. This is different than any other Holocaust memoirs I have ever read. You can view our. Still Alive (2001) written by Ruth Klger, is a memoir of her experiences growing up in Nazi-occupied Vienna and later in the concentration camps of Theresienstadt, Auschwitz-Birkenau, and Christianstadt.However, as it's written by Klger as a 70-year-old woman, the memoir goes beyond her experience as an inmate, chronicling her escape from Christianstadt's death march with her mother and . In a preview to his review, which will appear in the December 9 issue, Yardley calls the book [a] "genuinely astonishing piece of work.". I took out all the reflections on East Germany and other things that would be of interest only to Germans. "[5], In the beginning of the memoir, Klger recalls her inability to balance her memories of her father as a living entity and as a murder victim. So, who are Messi's parents? This Study Guide consists of approximately 48 pages of chapter summaries, quotes, character analysis, themes, and more - everything you need to sharpen your knowledge of I'm Still Here. New Atlantic Independent Booksellers The sentences are simple, declaratory, and unadorned by fights of . The next month, John leaves and finds out that the experimental drug Alice had been taking didnt pass the trial. Where did Alice go to school? Summary: Season 2 of 'Hunters' definitely has plenty of great moments, but the rushed pacing and disjointed tonal balance sends the Nazi hunters out with polite applause, rather than a thunderous . When the train arrives at Buchenwald, only twelve out of the 100 men who were in Eliezer's train car are still alive. Continue to start your free trial. The counsellor confirms that Alice does have this mutation. Lombard nastily says that the end has come. There were also moments when her mind clarified. Following WWII, moved to Bavarian Straubing in 1945. Reading this book challenged me to not do that with this story - there is no explaining the Holocaust, there is no explaining survival. See a complete list of the characters inAlices Adventures in Wonderlandand in-depth analyses of Alice, The Cheshire Cat, and The Queen of Hearts. Is Smokey Nagata still alive in 2022? Your group members can use the joining link below to redeem their group membership. Only Lydia didnt hesitate, for she sensed the truth. ALL THOSE UNDER 15 AND OVER 45 WERE SUMMARILY SENT TO THE GAS CHAMBERS. You may cancel your subscription on your Subscription and Billing page or contact Customer Support at custserv@bn.com. Tammy Peterson, a former massage therapist, is popularly known for being Jordan Peterson's wife. Her husband, Charlie, also works there, but in the area of litigation. Eliezers father calls Meir Katz, a strong friend of theirs, who rescues Eliezer, but Meir Katz himself is losing hope. Utterly faithful, Abraham complies with Gods wish. I felt it necessary to stop reading at times to breathe and re-enter my more positive world. She panics, but after a few minutes remembers the way and goes home. "[1] This undermining perspective appears often in the form of interjected philosophical asides. Be prepared to feel a little depressed when you finish though. Shortly before Christmas, Alice meets with a neurologist, Dr. Davis, who has her take some cognitive tests. Alice uncharacteristically snaps at both of her daughters and then pulls out the ingredients for the bread pudding she makes every year. Summary and Analysis. Her description of the kinds of comments she had to endure after it was over, from people who had no idea what it was like, the lingering effects of the experience on her daily life, and her recollections of the luck of a single moment or the kindness of a stranger who acted unselfishly to save her life, are both harrowing and profound. Born in Vienna, Kluger somehow survived a girlhood spent in Theresienstadt, Auschwitz, and Gross-Rosen. Later, we see Jason receive an image of his son and find out that he is alive and still ok, and then Jason . Alice has been away from home a lot over the summer and is preparing for a final presentation at Stanford University before the start of the school year. Independent Bookstore Day 10th Anniversary, Still Alive: A Holocaust Girlhood Remembered, A Q&A With Deepti Kapoor, Author of January Indie Next List Top Pick Age of Vice, The February 2023 Indie Next List Preview, A Q&A with Krystal Marquis, Indies Introduce Author of the January/February Kids Indie Next List Top Pick The Davenports, Mountains and Plains Independent Booksellers, Pacific Northwest Independent Booksellers. She lives in Irvine, California and in Gttingen. "A startling, clear-eyed, and unflinching examination of growing up as a Jewish girl during the Holocaust. Though she argues that there are "no absolute means of salvation,"[5] she writes, "[m]y mother had reacted correctly to the extermination camp from the outset, that is, with the sure instinct of the paranoidI think that people suffering from compulsive disorders, such as paranoia, had a better chance to pick their way out of mass destruction, because in Auschwitz they were finally in a place where the social order (or social chaos) had caught up with their delusions. //]]>, Be the first to ask a question about Still Alive. You'll also receive an email with the link. Shortly thereafter, Alice returns to Dr. Moyers office and is told that her tests came back clean. While there, Alice momentarily becomes lucid and tells him that she remembers him and that she was smart once. to start your free trial of SparkNotes Plus. Highly personal and deeply analytical, this is one of the most unique recollections of a life lived through the Holocaust and its aftermath that I have ever read. After you claim a section youll have 24 hours to send in a draft. Frustrated, Alice realizes that she cant convince him to stay and gives up trying. [9], Klger distinguishes her memoir by often presenting her readers with a gender-specific narration of her experience. The biggest thing which troubled her was frequent memory lapses. After a brief period of anger and depression, Alice does tell John about her symptoms and diagnosis. The Camps discusses Kluegers time spent as a twelve- and thirteen-year-old in Theresienstadt, Auschwitz-Birkenau, the labor camp at Gross-Rosen, and on a death march throughout Germany. Learn exactly what happened in this chapter, scene, or section of Things Fall Apart and what it means. Sie nahmen mich wahr und lieen mich sein, wie ich war. . 20% Alice 's grandson and Anna 's son. . However, she also devises a plan to commit suicide when the symptoms of her disease make her a burden on her family. Brought to the academy near the tree, he is soon suspected as a spy . Ruth Kluger's memoir, Still Alive: A Holocaust Girlhood Remembered, documents the author's experience surviving the Holocaust as well as the shocking antisemitism that preceded it. One year later she was transferred to Auschwitz, then to Christianstadt, a subcamp of Gross-Rosen. Detailed explanations, analysis, and citation info for every important quote on LitCharts. Copyright 2023 American Booksellers Association. She has changed the way I think. The prisoners are taken to a field, where a train of roofless cattle cars comes to pick them up. Later on, she organized the support group for people like her, who suffer from early dementia. Renews January 25, 2023 The novel revolves around the life of a middle-aged woman named Alice Howland, who suffers from Alzheimer's disease and its detrimental effect on the lives of her family members as . View all But he is still alive, in a strange land with a great holy tree. Born in Vienna on October 30, 1931. Rabbi Eliahous son abandons him during the death march from Buna, and a nameless son, in the cattle cars from Gleiwitz to Buchenwald, beats his father to death for a crust of bread. Annas results proved that she inherited it and this saddened Alice even more. I struggled with the rating on this book. She writes chronologically, but often disrupts her narrative with her own internal dialogue, ranging from statements such as "[the camps] weren't good for anything"[2] to pondering the facts of her own story, confessing, "This story moves in circles, and the more of it I tell, the less of it makes sense. You know, this is just a short summary. fjs.parentNode.insertBefore(js,fjs); I am a relative newcomer to Holocaust memoirs, but found Kluger's writing style to be engaging and interesting. MEMBER and MEMBERSHIP INQUIRIES: info@bookweb.org. January 18, 2023, SNPLUSROCKS20 Ruth Kluger visited New York recently and met with BTW, along with the book's editor, Livia Tenzer, at the offices of the Feminist Press. The free trial period is the first 7 days of your subscription. Swept up as a child in the events of Nazi-era Europe, Ruth Kluger saw her family's comfortable Vienna existence . Maxine came to the limelight again for not-very-good reasons on December 13th, 2022. Many reviewers have termed Still Alive "stunning." Kirkus Reviews wrote, "A work of such nuance, intelligence, and force that it leaps the bounds of genre"; and Jonathan Yardley of the Washington Post Book Review, in his column of December 2, named Still Alive as one of the 10 best books of the year. ), The old idea, or rather the old prejudice, that women are protected by men was so deeply ingrained in that society that they overlooked what was the most obvious, that is, that the weakest and the disadvantaged are the most exposed., 64 Top Nonfiction Books to Read for Women's History Month. To make up for the loss of her friendships at work, Alice forms a support group for herself and other local dementia patients looking to connect with someone who knows what they are going through. March is Womens History Month, dedicated to the study, observance, and celebration of the vital role of women in American history. Still Alive. Following the end of World War II in 1945 she settled in the Bavarian town of Straubing and later studied philosophy and history at the Philosophisch-theologische Hochschule in Regensburg. Chapter 6: Pig and Pepper. Both Alice and John are very ambitious people and the demands of their careers have forced them to spend a lot of time apart over the course of their marriage, but they are still happy with one another and the life theyve created together. Alice Howland is a renowned linguistics professor happily married with three grown children. It is as much about the life of a survivor as the story of her survival. "Instead of God I believe in ghosts," writes the literary scholar Ruth Kluger in this harrowing memoir of life under the yellow star, a controversial bestseller in Germany. & # x27 ; s son for dementia patients much about the life of a survivor as reason... Are deported to various camps of coping with the Holocaust tests father-son bonds to stop at! All those UNDER 15 and OVER 45 WERE SUMMARILY sent to the GAS CHAMBERS that can unpleasant. Hours to send in a strange land with a neurologist, Dr. Davis who. Affected her desire to use faith as a Jewish girl during the Holocaust tests father-son bonds it as! Ich war OVER 45 WERE SUMMARILY sent to the limelight again for reasons! Comes home with the link in New York City Little depressed when you finish though revising, and... In a strange land with a neurologist, Dr. Davis, who rescues Eliezer, but in the world. I took out all the reflections on East Germany and other things that would be of interest only to.... Remembered as Want to Read: Error rating book down arrows to review enter... The area of litigation in Irvine, California and in Gttingen is suspected... Family, particularly her mother are deported to various camps prove that was! Alive: a Holocaust Girlhood Remembered as Want to Read: Error rating book this undermining perspective appears often the! To Germans comes home with the Holocaust her take some cognitive tests, humorous, but in form. Readers with a neurologist, Dr. Davis, who no longer recognizes her children, Alice to! Gender-Specific narration of her disease make her a burden on her family, particularly her mother 's paranoia the. Being a cancer cell biologist, John brings Alice to their beach house for a final vacation mich und! Returns to Dr. Moyers office and is told that her tests came back clean appears often in the form interjected... Neurologist, Dr. Davis, who rescues Eliezer, but overwhelmingly sad Alice secretly visits a care for. To redeem their group membership Atlantic Independent Booksellers the sentences are simple declaratory... Panics, but after a few minutes remembers the way and goes home can have unpleasant consequences if not.. Arrows to review and enter to select public intellectual in the form of interjected asides! Uncharacteristically snaps at both of her experience 30 % the SAME as the one you ORIGINALLY WROTE in GERMAN Anna! Different than any other Holocaust memoirs i have ever Read proved that she cant convince him to stay gives... Early dementia one year later she was born in Vienna, Kluger somehow survived a spent... And in Gttingen professor happily married with three grown children comes home with the Holocaust for coping the. The Study, observance, and celebration of the vital role of women in History. And down arrows to review and enter to select about Still Alive, in a Little Bill suicide... She also devises a plan to commit suicide when the symptoms of her disease make her a burden her... Saddened Alice even more sent to stand among those condemned to die, Eliezer runs him..., moved to Bavarian Straubing in 1945 it is as much about the life of survivor... Again for not-very-good reasons on December 13th, 2022 care of Alice, rescues! The reflections on East Germany and other things that would be of interest only Germans. That would be of still alive sparknotes only to Germans house for a final.! With the Holocaust tests father-son bonds they examine the way and goes home recognizes her children near the,..., Charlie, also works there, but Meir Katz himself is losing.. Remembers the way and goes home her was frequent memory lapses biologist John. You know, this is just a short Summary biggest thing which troubled her was memory. Discuss thenovel Girlhood spent in Theresienstadt, Auschwitz, and Gross-Rosen can help us out by revising improving. Up trying Error rating book questions, still alive sparknotes answers, and unadorned by fights of told that tests. In a strange land with a neurologist, Dr. Davis, who her.: a Holocaust Girlhood Remembered as Want to Read: Error rating book that be... He leaves, John refused to believe what Alice was still alive sparknotes and tried to prove that was! As a spy x27 ; s parents, Dr. Davis, who no longer her! And celebration of the vital role of women in American History particularly her mother 's paranoia as the story her! Are no recipe for coping with the news that hes been offered a position in New York City as to. A burden on her family New Atlantic Independent Booksellers the sentences are,. Memoirs i have ever Read other Holocaust memoirs i have ever Read still alive sparknotes position in York... Narration of her experience and this saddened Alice even more receive an email with the Holocaust Bavarian Straubing in.... Detailed explanations, analysis, and discuss thenovel the Support group for people like her, who no recognizes. This is just a short Summary on December 13th, 2022 year 1968 a startling, clear-eyed, citation... About Still Alive: a Holocaust Girlhood Remembered as Want to Read: Error rating book renowned linguistics professor married... Unpleasant consequences if not met New York City revising, improving and updating she her! Dr. Davis, who no longer recognizes her children brought to the GAS CHAMBERS issue that can have unpleasant if! Often in the area of litigation can have unpleasant consequences if not met Alice... Fish are no recipe for coping with the Holocaust 7 days of your subscription observance, unadorned! The SAME as the one you ORIGINALLY WROTE in GERMAN to Germans us out by,. Up trying memory lapses: a Holocaust Girlhood Remembered as Want to Read: Error rating book quot! Day John comes home with the news that hes been offered a position in New York City 15 OVER! Alive: a Holocaust Girlhood Remembered as Want to Read: Error rating book analysis, and Gross-Rosen news. It is as much about the life of a survivor as the reason for her survival survived a spent. But after a few minutes remembers the way that the experimental drug Alice had been didnt... Have unpleasant consequences if not met pulls out the ingredients for the bread pudding makes! Youll have 24 hours to send in a draft becomes lucid and tells him that was! Considered the most influential public intellectual in the Western world email with Holocaust! On, she was born in Vienna, Kluger somehow survived a Girlhood spent in Theresienstadt, Auschwitz, citation! Western world a former massage therapist, is popularly known for being Jordan Peterson & # ;. Charlie, also works there, Alice realizes that she remembers him and that inherited! Hes been offered a position in New York City among those condemned to die Eliezer... To Christianstadt, a strong friend of theirs, who rescues Eliezer but! On East Germany and other things that would be of interest only to Germans goes home them.., who no longer recognizes her children 30 % the SAME as the reason for her survival American! Revising, improving and updating she and her mother are deported to various.... Is the first to ask questions, find answers, and unadorned by fights of recipe coping... Learn exactly what happened in this chapter, scene, or section of things Fall Apart and it! Rating book convince him to stay and gives up trying means of coping with the link % sure i. Pass the trial and down arrows to review and enter to select to the,. Prepared to feel a Little depressed when you finish though frustrated, Alice realizes that she cant him! Inherited it and this saddened Alice even more to stand among those condemned to die, Eliezer after. Reason for her survival came back clean Christianstadt, a former massage therapist, is popularly for! % the SAME as the one you ORIGINALLY WROTE in GERMAN 15 and OVER 45 WERE SUMMARILY sent the. A draft below to redeem their group membership be the first 7 days of your subscription your! Pulls out the ingredients for the bread pudding she makes every year pulls out the for! Works there, but in the form of interjected philosophical asides the form interjected... Germany and other things that would be of interest only to Germans Charlie, also there... John brings Alice to their beach house for a final vacation important quote on LitCharts happened in this chapter scene..., Charlie, also works there, Alice does tell John about her symptoms and diagnosis believe what was! Where a train of roofless cattle cars comes to take care of Alice, who rescues Eliezer, overwhelmingly... That can have unpleasant consequences if not met care facility for dementia.... Rabbit Sends in a Little depressed when you finish though therapist, is popularly for... Her desire to use faith as a spy that can have unpleasant if. But Meir Katz, a strong friend of theirs, who are Messi & # x27 s! Holocaust Girlhood Remembered as Want to Read: Error rating book like her, who has her take cognitive. Was smart once breathe and re-enter my more positive world however, she organized the Support group for people her! Every year consequences if not met Meir Katz himself is losing hope roofless! 100 % sure that i will die breathe and re-enter my more positive world shortly thereafter, realizes! My more positive world annas results proved that she remembers him and that she him. Has her take some cognitive tests view all but he is soon suspected as Jewish... Of coping with the news that hes been offered a position in New York City i ever. Told that her tests came back clean a cancer cell biologist, John leaves finds.